Stocking Stuffers Under $5

KONG AirDog Squeakair Ball Dog Toy

$3.99

Blue Buffalo Bits Tender Beef Natural Soft Moist Training Dog Treats

$4.99

Sale

Blue Buffalo Bits Tasty Chicken Natural Soft-Moist Training Treats

$4.99

Sale

Petsense Logo Classic Tennis Ball Dog Toy

$0.99

Temptations Tasty Chicken Flavor Cat Treats

From$2.59

Sale

Blue Buffalo Bits Tempting Turkey Natural Soft-Moist Training Treats

$4.99

Sale

Blue Buffalo Sizzlers Bacon-Style Dog Treats

$4.99

Sale

Blue Buffalo Health Bars Natural Crunchy Dog Treats Biscuits, Apple & Yogurt 16 oz. Bag

$4.98

Sale

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Duck Wild Bits Dog Treats

$4.99

Sale

Redbarn Lamb Ear Dog Chew

$1.19

Sale

Blue Buffalo Health Bars Natural Crunchy Dog Treats Biscuits, Bacon, Egg & Cheese 16 oz. Bag

$4.98

Sale

KONG Plush Duck Dog Toy

$3.49

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken & Duck Cat Treats

$2.99

Sale

Ultimates Jerky Lamb Mini Sticks Grain-Free Dog Treats

$4.99

Milk-Bone GravyBones Dog Biscuits - Small, 19-Ounce

$3.99

Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy

$4.99

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Salmon Wild Bits Dog Treats

$4.99

Sale

Petsense Disc Dog Toy

$1.99

Sale

Redbarn 5" Bully Stick Dog Chew

$3.49

Sale

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken & Turkey Cat Treats

$2.99

Sale

Temptations Hearty Beef Flavor Cat Treats

From$2.59

Sale

Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy

$4.99

Temptations Creamy Dairy Flavor Cat Treats

From$2.59

Mammoth Pet Flossy Chews Mini 6 inch 100% Cotton White Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.99

Sale

Pro Pac Smoky Sausage Bites Moist Dog Treats

$1.99

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Chicken Wild Bits Dog Treats

$4.99

Sale

Purina Dentalife Adult Tasty Chicken Flavor Cat Dental Treats

$1.99

Redbarn 7" Bully Stick Dog Chew

$4.79

Sale

Milk-Bone Original Dog Biscuits, Small Crunchy Dog Treats, 24 Ounces

$3.99

Temptations Seafood Medley Flavor Cat Treats

$3.99

Sale

Kaytee Apple Orchard Sticks 10 Count

$4.29

Mammoth Pet Flossy Chews Mini 6 inch Cottonblend Color Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.99

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Butterfly & Mylar Wand Assorted

$4.59

Milk-Bone Soft and Chewy Dog Treats, Beef & Filet Mignon Recipe With Chuck Roast, 5.6oz Bag

$3.99

Fruitables Baked Pumpkin Blueberry 7oz

$4.99

Mammoth Pet Mini 10-in Cotton-Poly Color 3 Knot Rope Tug Dog Toy

$2.09

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Mini Teaser Wands Assorted

$4.19

Grillerz Pork Femur Dog Chew Treat

$3.99

Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy

$4.99

JW Cat Crazies Cat Toy

$4.49

Milk-Bone Soft and Chewy Dog Treats, Chicken Recipe With Chicken Breast, 5.6oz bag

$3.99

Ultimates Jerky Beef Sticks Grain-Free Dog Treats

$4.99

Blue Buffalo Bursts Filled Seafood Cat Treats

$1.69

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Grain Free Soft-Moist Cat Treats, Chicken & Salmon 2 oz. Bag

$2.98

Sale

Oxbow Animal Health Simple Rewards Baked Treats with Apple & Banana

$3.89

Sale

Ultimates Jerky Chicken Mini Strips Grain-Free Dog Treats

$4.99

Pro Pac Beef Flavored Woof 'Em Down Sticks Dog Treats

$1.99

Bil-Jac 4 oz Little Gooberlicious Dry Dog Treat

$4.99

Sale