Stocking Stuffers Under $5

KONG AirDog Squeakair Ball Dog Toy

$3.99

Petsense Logo Classic Tennis Ball Dog Toy

$0.99

Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Wide Cat Toy

$4.99

Petsense Disc Dog Toy

$1.99

Sale

Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy

$4.99

Mammoth Pet Flossy Chews Mini 6 inch 100% Cotton White Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.99

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Butterfly & Mylar Wand Assorted

$4.59

Mammoth Pet Mini 10-in Cotton-Poly Color 3 Knot Rope Tug Dog Toy

$2.09

Sale

KONG Phatz Pig Plush Dog Toy

From$4.99

Mammoth Pet Flossy Chews Mini 6 inch Cottonblend Color Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.99

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Mini Teaser Wands Assorted

$4.19

Ethical Pet Colorful Springs Thin Cat Toy

$4.99

JW Cat Crazies Cat Toy

$4.49

Ethical Products SPOT Kitty Fun Boppers Assorted 4"

$3.79

Outward Hound Invincibles Mini Duck Dog Toy XS

$4.99

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Lattice Balls Plastic With Bell 4 Pack

$3.09

KONG Active Feather Teaser Cat Toy

$4.79

Mammoth Pet Mini 11-in Color 3 Knot Tug with Mini Tennis Ball Dog Toy

$4.19

Sale

Multipet Loofa Latex Assorted Colors Dog Toy

$4.99

Sale

Mammoth Pet Sm 15-in Cotton-Poly Color 3 Knot Rope Tug Dog Toy

$3.89

Sale

Mammoth Pet Small 9-in Cotton-Poly Color Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.79

Sale

Outward Hound Invincibles Mini Hedgehog Dog Toy XS

$4.99

Sale

Ethical Pet Bambone Dog Toy, Chicken Flavor

From$3.99

Chuckit! Tennis Ball Dog Toy

From$4.49

JW Playplace Lattice Ball Dog Toy

$4.49

Nylabone Moderate Chew FlexiChew Dental Chew Toy Textured Bone Chicken X-Small up to 15 lbs.

$4.27

Sale

Mammoth Pet Small 9-in 100% Cotton White Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.79

Sale

Patchwork Pet PatchCat Fruit Set Cat Toy

$4.49

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Plush Soccer Ball 4.5"

$4.59

Mammoth Pet Mini 10-in Twister Pull Tug with Mini Ball Dog Toy

$4.89

Sale

Mammoth Pet Medium 12-in 100% Cotton White Rope Bone Dog Toy

$3.89

Sale

Mammoth Pet Med. 3.75-in EXTRA Monkey Fist Ball with Handle Dog Toy

$4.89

Sale

Jackson Galaxy Sprial LED Balls Cat Toy

$4.99

Patchwork Pet PatchCat Bath Time Set Cat Toy

$4.49

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Plush Basketball Dog Toy

$4.59

Ethical Products SPOT Plush Football 4.5"

$4.59