Stocking Stuffers Under $5

Howl's Kitchen 12OZ Beef & Cheese Flavor Wraps Dog Treats

$4.99

Outward Hound Invincibles Mini Hedgehog Dog Toy XS

$4.99

Sale

Ethical Pet Bambone Dog Toy, Chicken Flavor

From$3.99

JW Playplace Lattice Ball Dog Toy

$4.49

Redbarn Beef Filled Hooves Dog Treats

$4.99

Wellness Natural Grain Free Crunchy Puppy Bites Chicken and Carrots Recipe Dog Treats

$4.99

Blue Buffalo Bursts Filled Chicken Liver & Beef Cat Treats

$1.69

Sale

A&E Cage Nibbles Small Animal Hay Chew Bite

$0.99

Sale

TEMPTATIONS MIXUPS Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Catnip Fever Flavor, 6.3 oz. Pouch

$3.99

Sale

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Blissful Catnip Flavor, 3 oz. Pouch

$2.59

Sale

Nylabone Moderate Chew FlexiChew Dental Chew Toy Textured Bone Chicken X-Small up to 15 lbs.

$4.27

Sale

Bil-Jac 4 oz Little Jacs Dry Dog Treat

$4.99

Sale

Mammoth Pet Mini 10-in Twister Pull Tug with Mini Ball Dog Toy

$4.89

Sale

Mammoth Pet Medium 12-in 100% Cotton White Rope Bone Dog Toy

$3.89

Sale

Mammoth Pet Med. 3.75-in EXTRA Monkey Fist Ball with Handle Dog Toy

$4.89

Sale

Mammoth Pet Small 9-in 100% Cotton White Rope Bone Dog Toy

$2.79

Sale

Butchers Block Butcher Bones Beef Femur Knuckle End Dog Bone

$4.68

Redbarn Cheese and Bacon Filled Hooves Dog Treats

$4.99

Sale

Friskies Party Mix Beachside Crunch Cat Treats

$3.59

Blue Health Bars Baked With Banana & Yogurt Dog Treats

$4.99

Higgins Sunburst Gourmet Treats Veggie Stix

$3.99

Wellness Kittles Crunchy Salmon & Cranberry Cat Treats

$2.49

Patchwork Pet PatchCat Fruit Set Cat Toy

$4.49

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Plush Soccer Ball 4.5"

$4.59

Redbarn Pig Snout Dog Treats

$2.99

Sale

Solid Gold Bone Broth Turkey for Dogs

$4.99

Higgins Sunburst Gourmet Treats Soak n' Sprout

$2.99

Higgins Sunburst Gourmet Treats Fruits & Veggies Large

$4.19

Smakers Vita Burger Treat Assorted Flavors Vegetable, Fruit, and Nut

$3.99

Smakers Small Animal Ice Cream Cone Treat

$4.99

WHIMZEES by Wellness Natural Daily Dental Long Lasting Dog Treats, Medium Veggie Strip

$2.39

Sale

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Crunchy Cat Treats, Salmon 2 oz. Bag

$1.88

Sale

Jones Natural Chews Stuffed Beef Hooves Chicken N Rice Flavor Dog Chew

$4.99

A&E Cage Company 6" Flavored Cuttlebone for Birds

$3.99

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Tasty Chicken Flavor, 6.3 oz. Pouch

$3.99

Sale

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Creamy Dairy Flavor, 6.3 oz. Pouch

$3.99

Sale

Patchwork Pet PatchCat Bath Time Set Cat Toy

$4.49

Sale

Ethical Products SPOT Plush Basketball Dog Toy

$4.59

Ethical Products SPOT Plush Football 4.5"

$4.59

Milk-Bone Comfort Chews, Dog Treats with Unique Chewy Texture and Real Beef

$4.99

Milk-Bone Mini Comfort Chews, Dog Treats with Unique Chewy Texture and Real Beef

$4.99

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Shrimpy Shrimp Flavor, 6.3 oz. Pouch

$3.99

Sale

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Shrimpy Shrimp Flavor, 3 oz. Pouch

$2.59

JW Bird Millet Spray Holder

$3.59

TEMPTATIONS MIXUPS Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Surfer's Delight Flavor, 6.3 oz. Pouch

$3.99

Sale

TEMPTATIONS Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats Savory Salmon Flavor, 6.3 oz. Pouch

$3.99